Amidst the debates around diversity in the Hugo Awards I
said on a panel at the 2015 World Horror convention that I don’t read HP
Lovecraft. Now, at a horror convention
that comment fell like a pin dropped, everyone went silent. I went on to explain why I don’t think black
horror or Sci-fi writers need to read Lovecraft to become good horror writers. There
is a big difference between African American concepts of horror and that of HP
Lovecraft. They differ in their
interpretation of what death is, what are dead people and what should we do to
the dead.
First, let’s define what HP Lovecraft horror is or better
what Lovecraftian horror is. HP Lovecraft is now regarded as one of the most significant
20th-century authors in his genre. His
style of horror is one of the most revered.
Lovecraftian horror is a subgenre of horror fiction that emphasizes the
cosmic horror of the unknown. Its basic
tenants are Unanswered questions, Detachment from society and, Helplessness and
hopelessness all with a Antiquarian writing style. While everything in horror isn’t exactly like
Lovecraft, he is the poster child for Western horror. It was a bust of him which was used as the
World Fantasy awards trophy from their inception through 2015.
Let me use my book It Happened on Negro Mountain to
illustrate my hypothesis. In my story
Negro Mountain (a real place in Maryland) is protected by the spirit of an
escaped African during the time of American slavery. The story follows a young
girl who becomes emotionally terrorized by her father in the presence of her
mother. As the father’s (a drug dealing
gangster) threats and other activities become more prominent the ghost of the
dead African comes to the aid of the little girl. The story follows as the ghost terrorizes and
kills anyone who does bad things on the mountain.
My story while it sounds good, it is very unique among
horror stories. What makes it so unique
is that it is a good ghost story and still a scary horror story. You can count on one hand the amount of good
ghost stories that have achieved commercial success. In fact, I only know of two stories with good
ghosts that have succeeded in popular culture. Casper the friendly and Ghost
the movie with Whoopie Goldberg are the only two I know. That said, the difference between the
elements in my story and that of a western horror story is the difference of
cultural interpretation of death.
In western Lovecraft stories concepts like ghosts and dead
things are equivalent to evil and bad.
Even the use of the word dead is synonymous to evil. However, in African American culture or its
root African cultures dead and spirits are more good than bad. In African cultures when humans die they
become ancestors. Africans view their
ancestors as protectors and sources of aid and assistance. They are able to do both good and bad. This is a fundamental difference between
horror interpretations.
As with all of Lovecraftian concepts they depend on this
different interpretation. Instead of
praise for the dead Lovecraftian stories depend on fear and hate of the
dead. While African cultural stories
seek help from their dead western Lovecraftian stories run from and fight their
dead.
I wind this up by saying as we seek diversity in science
fiction and horror we must not allow for variations to be blurred. If African American writers begin to study HP
Lovecraft and start writing Lovecraftian stories then we are really missing out
on all of what we have been asking for. With
my book It Happened on Negro Mountain I have proven that good ghost stories can
be just as scary. The motto of Negro
Mountain is it is a place where bad things happen to bad people. I ask everyone to join me in enjoying this
expanse of the beloved genre of horror and ask African American writers to keep
away from HP Lovecraft.
Bio
Jeff Carroll is a writer and a filmmaker. He is pioneering what he calls Hip Hop
horror, Sci/fi and fantasy. His stories always have lots of action and a social
edge. He has written and produced 2
films and six books. Jeff Carroll is
also the author of the non-fiction book The Hip Hop Dating Guide. Connect with him at his blog
http://hhcnf.blogspot.com/ and on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.
Hello there, my name is Darci Lyne, I am from a new jersey, USA. I read a post-comment online of a Los Angeles Based Journalist Reveals How he Permanently Cured Weak Erection & Quick Ejaculation 2 months after His wife Left Him and he also said Dr. NOSA makes his ex-wife return back after 2year of separation. I contacted the same Dr. NOSA because of my challenges in life, I have these Powerful Intentions that things will work for me, I believed in testimonies are real-life proves. I realized this would be good to share here as I know it will inspire others too.
ReplyDeleteI was so lucky to come across BLACK MAGIC SPELLS
Caster personal contact
-Email- blackmagicsolutions95@gmail.com
I'm not sure I could have done it without him. I would have given up and believed that because my husband was seeing someone else and he said we were done. After Dr.NOSA launched a Magic Love-spell, my husband calls me on the cell phone and he returns back home. Thank you so much for bringing back my husband home after 3 years of separation. We are forever indebted. today I'm testifying with joy and happiness to the world...also, you can
WhatsApp with him-- +2349083639501
* Love Spells Win-Back Ex lover
* Success & promotion magic spell
* lucky charm - BUSINESS STAR
* wards - PROTECTIVE HOOK
* curse resolution
Divorce problem solution?
solution to sickness and diseases of the body
want a love spell for a new lover?
* spiritual cleansing
* fertility magic - FRUITS OF WOMEN